A few weeks ago, The New York Times published a report outlining questionable and disturbing aspects of NewJeans’ original contract with ADOR, sparking a massive online response. Recently, another publication, Cosmopolitan, published a piece referencing the controversy, and somehow, ALLDAY PROJECT member Annie has gotten entangled in it all.
Disturbing Details Of NewJeans’ Contract With ADOR Spark Massive Backlash
The Cosmopolitan article’s primary focus is another HYBE girl group, KATSEYE. But while talking about the “K-Pop” aspect of the group’s concept, it touched upon NewJeans’ contract controversy, largely dismissing the criticism as a “white-savior complex.” The writer argued that such contracts and trainee systems have existed in K-Pop way before the industry was globalized, and that “outsiders” criticizing the K-Pop industry culture were largely unaware of how it is shaped by South Korea’s “distinct historical, political, and socioeconomic landscape.”
These aspects of K-pop are deeply normalized within the industry itself: Trainee systems are shown openly in documentaries and TV series, including ones the companies themselves help produce, and artists often talk about those years candidly, suggesting that many of them may not see these practices as the problem outsiders do. And maybe there is also a truth in the idea that K-pop’s impressive commercial success is partly a product of the very controls critics object to, including the symbiotic relationships between artists and their labels, and between artists and their fans. Without that culture, we would probably not have what we now know to be BLACKPINK or BTS.
— Cosmopolitan
This argument has not sat well with most fans, and their rage only got amplified when they realized that the piece was written by Taylor Moon, the sister of ALLDAY PROJECT’s Annie. Social media was soon inundated with biting criticism, as many saw the writer’s opinion as reflecting her socioeconomic standing as a “Chaebol,” coming from one of South Korea’s richest families.
“from a western perspective” and cosmopolitan proceeds to give such an unhinged dystopian take glazed in paragraphs atrociously stitched to water down the nyt exposé on a alr decaying toxified kpop industry that gamifies idols in pursuit of capitalist bliss…that’s being “woke” https://t.co/RyhKCkfqxa
— PoppyKPoppie (@PoppyKPoppie) November 20, 2026
this is such a poorly written and irresponsible opinion piece from the author, Sister of ADP’s Annie Moon and and the Samsung heiress basically just wagging their fingers at ppl at the west for reacting to the recent news with katseye and new jean’s contract https://t.co/d683zIJizv
— igaddafi soya (@HiHiJets_twt) November 20, 2026
Now we got chaebols invalidating NewJeans and brushing off the toxic kpop system. And since she mainly wrote about KATSEYE, what they’re going through is bad too and they don’t deserve to be invalidated either. Like what is going on here lol https://t.co/OyyEP0aXah
— Bre 🧭SKZ•GOT7💚 (@BreElainee) November 20, 2026
when you let the granddaughter of Chaebol family talk about human rights. it will come out like this 55555555 https://t.co/sHQxiJmo1k
— benegrazie (@benegrazieciao) November 20, 2026
This Cosmopolitan article being written by the sister of Annie from ALLDAYPROJECT – the chaebols. Brushing a human rights issue off & putting all blame on the west is insane.
“Outsiders interfering in the methods & systems that have existed without their attention for decades.” https://t.co/i2tUwFNpyS
— Bre 🧭SKZ•GOT7💚 (@BreElainee) November 20, 2026
chaebol heiress defending slave contracts 😭😭 #ok
— 🐇 #HIGHBEAM (@xngmates) November 20, 2026
Though most netizens have maintained the nuanced position not to blame Annie for this controversial take, it inevitably adds to the pressure the idol has already faced for her privileged family background.
ALLDAY PROJECT’s “Chaebol” Annie Is Being Criticized For “Illegal” Pre-Debut Activities

