Netizens have mixed opinions on the issue.
1 hour ago
Recently, fans slammed SM Entertainment for the announcement of Hearts2Hearts Ian‘s solo stage.
Hearts2Hearts’ Ian | @IanToT1009/Twitter
Particularly, many were upset that the song she performed (“UP” by aespa‘s Karina) has never been performed by Karina herself on a major stage.
aespa’s Karina “Robbed” Of Major Opportunity By SM Entertainment, Sparking Outrage
Her special stage recently took place and triggered heated reactions.
[Video could not be displayed]
Many fans felt that Ian did well and showed off her idol skills, despite being a rookie.
[Video could not be displayed]
Meanwhile, some were not impressed and were not in favor of the performance.
she’s a mess https://t.co/1OAyJEXK7F
— Kiara (@aenovaaa) December 31, 2025
Performing a song that the original artist never had the opportunity to perform at major shows is absurd. https://t.co/JrtwLXG4j2
— sowaerbi (@nemopilema_) December 31, 2025
should’ve just let karina perform her damn song sigh.. https://t.co/EEu7cQ7qyB pic.twitter.com/9rWapPQJJw
— aji (@kkiusgf) December 31, 2025
However, others felt she did a great job as her performance gained attention on Korean forum theqoo.
- “She’s killing it—this concept suits her so well, and she’s beautiful.”
- “Her arms are so long, it looks really graceful.”
- “Absolutely stunning.”
- “She performs so well on stage.”
- “Ah, she’s just too good.”
- “Her talent is the kind that’s meant for being an entertainer.”
| theqoo